Thursday November 23rd 2017


OK…in the interest of “full disclosure”…I am, and have always been a Van Halen fan.

From the moment I heard their debut in 1978, I was hooked. There’s something about Van Halen that has always (save for that little blip in 1998) been unique. It didn’t matter if it was Dave, or Sammy. When you heard Van Halen…you knew it was Van Halen.

There’s always been the argument; “They sold more records with Sammy.” First of all, that’s simply not true. According to the RIAA Van Halen have sold somewhere around 56-million records in the US. Now, that number has increased over the years, but assuming their stats are accurate as of right now (no pun intended) 34 million of those were DLR-era records. So, that argument is refuted.

Then there’s the “They had more hits with Sammy.” And this is absolutely true. The addition of Sammy Hagar to Van Halen absolutely made them a more inclusive musical entity. Prior to Sammy, Van Halen were more of a Hard Rock band, bordering on Heavy Metal. Sammy’s addition made their music much more palatable to the masses, and easier to exposure on Top-40 radio.

The fact is…this debate is probably the most intense, and hotly contested in Rock history. Everyone has an opinion. This isn’t like Steve Perry-Journey, or Brian Johnson vs. Bon Scott. Peter Gabriel vs. Phil Collins. None of them have raged on like the Van Halen lead singer argument. With apologies to my good friend Gary Cherone, Dave v. Sammy has been that element that both unites & divides Van Halen fans (and Rock fans on the whole).

The band’s dysfunction is as legendary as their musical output. Quick synopsis: All bands are dysfunctional. Dave quits in 1985. Band and ex-lead singer snipe each other in the press. Sammy joins. Lead singers snipe each other in the press. Sammy quits. Band and ex-lead singer snipe each other in the press. Dave returns for two songs. People rejoice. Internal dysfunction continues. Dave is out again. Cue sniping. Extreme frontman Gary Cherone joins. It’s an unwinnable situation. Band releases Van Halen III & tours. Record doesn’t sell. Gary is out. Sammy & Dave tour together? Ex-lead singers snipe each other in the press. Van Halen goes through period of inactivity. Sammy returns for “Greatest Hits Package & Tour” Edward Van Halen is in poor health. Tour concludes. Sammy is out again. Sniping? you bet! Original bassist Michael Anthony is also out. Band drafts Edward Van Halen’s son, Wolfgang to play bass. Dave comes back (again!). Band tours. Reports of dysfunction continue. Time heals all wounds. Band makes first full record of new material in 14 years, and first with DLR in 28. Sammy Hagar continues to snipe. Shockingly, DLR ignores the bait. Band plays secret shows in NY & LA. Reviews are strong.

That’s where we are today. Which brings me to my “review” of the forthcoming “A Different Kind Of Truth.” Which will be in stores Tuesday, Feb 7th.

I won’t go into a song-by-song review. Plenty of those will pop up around the ‘net soon enough. Yes, many of the tracks originally sought life in the 70s. This is not a new concept. Bands draw on past material all the time. Refreshing the tones and lyrics. Creating their music. It’s *their* music. Who cares when it was written? It’s being released now. I don’t get that argument at all.

The thing that strikes me about “A Different Kind Of Truth” is the *vibe* of Van Halen is present throughout. Highlights for me include “Blood & Fire” & “Stay Frosty”…which may already be my favorite Van Halen song of all time. What’s interesting is the fact that a 57-year old David Lee Roth has written lyrics that continue his unique ability to write absurd commentary without sounding silly or outdated. I won’t say it’s a maturity. I’d say it’s a comfort level. He knows he can write clever double-entendre. He also knows that writing the kind of stuff certain other ex-vocalists have written, comes off as an old man struggling to remain relevant to “the kids.”

This doesn’t happen on ADKOT.

The most striking element of the record is drummer Alex Van Halen. He “sounds happy.” It’s hard to put into words. The band sounds…right. He is in a groove. You’ve heard it said before that a record is an attempt to capture a mood. The band at a moment in time. They have done that. Once this album is heard by the masses, it will become clear.

The Dave vs. Sammy debate is clearly over. They made great music with Sammy. Even the doubters have to cop to that.

Sammy & Michael Anthony have a good band with their Chickenfoot outfit (which also features guitar hero Joe Satriani). They’ve released 2 CDs of their own and are playing this Spring/Summer at a club/theater near you.

But…They are the “Mighty Van Halen” with Dave. And, they’ll be frequenting the local hockey rink near you soon.

There’s nothing like Van Halen. Thank your deity of choice. You can’t put it into words. You just have to be able to hear it.

Like Free Gotham on Facebook...

5 Comments for “The…New…VAN HALEN”

  • Wayno A says:

    Well said Sir!!!

  • Vinny says:

    “You’ve heard it said before that a record is an attempt to capture a mood. The band at a moment in time.”

    This is a very true statement. There’s a certain energy that can make even a humbly produced record infectious — Motley’s Dr. Feelgood is one of the best produced rock records ever and I’d still rather listen to their demo-like Too Fast For Love. Van Halen has always been a unique band in the heavy music genre, and I think this has as much to do with Alex as it does Eddie. Alex’s swing approach to heavy music is original and killer. Thanks for acknowledging his contributions in your review.

  • baldylocks says:

    you couldn’t have articulated my thoughts more perfectly.
    this album is blowing me away. and although quite obviously missing mr. anthony’s underrated (understated) bass playing, as well as his standard-setting harmonies, this is a new original VH. they have been reconnected. after all of the bad circuitry, they have reconnected. and the light is blinding.

  • momo says:

    My sentiments exactly. I’ve been listening to an early review copy over the past few days and ADKOT will turn out to be one of my favorite VH releases. It rocks and smokes. All respect to Sammy but it was never the same. The chemistry with DLR and the band is just different. Now it feels and sounds like it should… The vocals, the harmonies, the creativity in the music, the band’s tightness, and Eddie’s amazing guitar playing.

  • Jill says:

    I don’t know what the three of you above are talking about. This song is nonsense. Absolutely bad. Bad. Bad. Bad.

Leave a Comment to Wayno A

More from category

The Cult Blows Through Terminal 5 in New York City
The Cult Blows Through Terminal 5 in New York City

On Friday June 8th, 2012, The Cult played to a packed house at New York City’s Terminal 5. Supporting their [Read More]

Gotham Interview with Nate Rockwell
Gotham Interview with Nate Rockwell

Write this down…Write This Down is a band you’ll want to keep your eyes out for in 2012. On June 5th, their [Read More]

Slipknot’s ‘Antennas To Hell’
Slipknot’s ‘Antennas To Hell’

On Monday, fans of Slipknot were given an early, and very confusing, Christmas present. No description accompanies the [Read More]

Jack White at Roseland Ballroom, Night One
Jack White at Roseland Ballroom, Night One

If there was ever a doubt about Jack White‘s place in rock and roll history, it was dismissed within 30 seconds [Read More]

Tremonti Video Premiere
Tremonti Video Premiere

You’ve heard it, now it’s time to see it. Tremonti debuted their live video for “You Waste Your [Read More]

Gotham Categories

Gotham Archives